Welcome to The EDU Ledger.com! We’ve moved from Diverse.
Welcome to The EDU Ledger! We’ve moved from Diverse: Issues In Higher Education.

Create a free The EDU Ledger account to continue reading

Colleges Offer More Basic Needs Help, but Few Track If It Keeps Students Enrolled, Guide Finds

Glass jar labeled 'College' with graduation cap icon, filled with dollar bills, surrounded by textbooks on wooden deskComplete College America (CCA) has called on colleges to stop simply tallying the food, housing, and emergency assistance they offer and to start measuring whether that help actually keeps students enrolled through graduation.

In a new 48-page guide, the Indianapolis-based nonprofit finds that while more institutions than ever provide basic needs services, many of those efforts lack strategic focus and the data to show what works. Titled “Refocus Your College's Basic Needs Support: A Guide to Directing Resources to Services That Improve Completion Rates,” the report asks colleges to build measurement systems that link support services to retention, completion and financial aid records and to steer limited dollars toward the interventions that move those numbers.

“Make no mistake: When a college's students are in crisis, the college's mission is in crisis,” said Dr. Yolanda Watson Spiva, president of CCA.

Watson Spiva said two decades of completion reforms have helped millions of students while revealing where the next barriers lie. 

“Too often, what pulls students off course isn't a math class,” she said. “It's losing a place to stay, an empty fridge, no ride to campus, or childcare that falls through. Meeting students’ basic needs is the next frontier of the completion agenda.”

The guide arrives as rising rents and food and transportation costs collide with an eroding federal safety net. CCA cites a 2024 survey by The Hope Center for Student Basic Needs at Temple University in which 73% of four-year college and university students reported some form of basic needs insecurity, including 41% who faced food insecurity, 48% who experienced housing insecurity and 14% who had been homeless. Yet 65% said they were unaware of campus resources designed to help.

The shortfall is just as stark at two-year schools. A 2025 survey by the Center for Community College Student Engagement found that 74% of community college students who needed help with rent or utility bills received no support from their college, and roughly half of those who needed help paying for food went without it.

The consequences fall hardest on students juggling family obligations. A 2025 U.S. Census Bureau working paper cited in the guide found that parenting students threatened with eviction complete degrees at less than half the rate of their peers. Roughly 30% of enrolled college students are parents of minor children or caregivers to an adult family member, and 44% of those caregivers consider stopping out, compared with 31% of their classmates.

The toll of those departures adds up nationally. Nearly one in five working-age Americans — 37.77 million adults ages 18 to 64 — has attended college but left without a degree or credential, according to a new National Student Clearinghouse Research Center report released this week. And while more than 1 million former students re-enrolled in 2024-25, the share returning held at 2.7% for a third consecutive year.

The report takes direct aim at a common campus reflex. Food pantries remain the most visible basic needs service at many colleges, and CCA acknowledges they provide essential emergency relief. But the guide rates standalone pantries, one-off emergency meal swipes and financial literacy programming as having weak evidence of meeting students' needs.

Interventions with the strongest track records, according to the guide's evidence tiers, include emergency grants, meal scholarships tied to on-campus dining, housing vouchers, free public transit and basic needs centers that help students enroll in public benefits. Rapid rehousing, childcare subsidies and on-campus mental health counseling earned moderate ratings.

CCA stops short of telling colleges to close their pantries, advising instead that they right-size such broad-access offerings so higher-impact programs get adequate funding. It is blunter about services that are failing, urging institutions to retire or redesign them even after significant investment.

“Student support staff are increasingly attuned to the barriers beyond the classroom that students are carrying,” said Meacie Fairfax, CCA's strategy director. “They're doing heroic work, often with a team of one or two, especially at small and rural colleges. But too often, they can't tell which services are keeping students enrolled.”

Working adults, student parents, and first-generation students “often face overlapping challenges that can make it difficult to stay enrolled,” she said. “Colleges need to recognize those warning signs early, before food insecurity, housing instability, transportation barriers, or caregiving responsibilities force a student out.”

The guide's centerpiece is a phased model of 10 metrics, beginning with data most campuses already collect.

In the first phase, institutions inventory their services across seven areas of need — childcare and other caregiving, financial stability, food, health care including mental health, housing, technology access, and transportation — and calculate a “capacity gap rate,” the share of student requests that are deferred, waitlisted or turned away. CCA recommends reallocating resources to any service where that rate reaches 15% or more.

The second phase gauges whether students know about available help, whether outreach prompts action and how often faculty make referrals. The final phase connects basic needs records to student information and financial aid systems to determine whether a student's situation stabilized and whether that student stayed enrolled. An intervention success rate below 50%, the guide says, signals that services are not matching what students actually need.

CCA also highlights a low-cost step: research shows that simply informing community college students about available supports and inviting them to use the help raised developmental education pass rates, credits earned and grades. Such nudging is one of the only basic needs interventions to meet the What Works Clearinghouse's standard for rigorous experimental evidence.

The guide estimates that launching the first phase requires two to four hours a week from a basic needs coordinator and 10 to 20 hours of institutional research time, and it notes that a simple Excel dashboard is sufficient to start. Most internal data linkages for institutional improvement, it adds, are permissible under the Family Educational Rights and Privacy Act's school official exception.

The report also outlines how state systems can scale the work through common metrics, shared data infrastructure and technical assistance to campuses.

Several states are already moving. New Mexico conducted the nation's first statewide student basic needs survey, and its legislature has funded food security efforts at every public campus, including tribal colleges. Kentucky built a statewide basic needs data dashboard through its Council on Postsecondary Education. California requires basic needs coordinators on every public college campus, and Oregon mandates a single point of contact for basic needs at its public institutions.

“Meeting students' basic needs is central to student success,” said Dr. Aaron Thompson, president of the Kentucky Council on Postsecondary Education. “That's why we built a basic needs data dashboard, so Kentucky's colleges can see the challenges their students face and measure whether our supports are working.”

Thompson said these issues will be explored at the state’s annual Student Success Summit, scheduled for March. 

CCA said it will offer assessments and coaching to colleges and states that want help implementing the guide.

The trusted source for all job seekers
We have an extensive variety of listings for both academic and non-academic positions at postsecondary institutions.
Read More
The trusted source for all job seekers