Welcome to The EDU Ledger.com! We’ve moved from Diverse.
Welcome to The EDU Ledger! We’ve moved from Diverse: Issues In Higher Education.

Create a free The EDU Ledger account to continue reading

School Phone Bans Slash Cellphone Use but Show Little Academic Benefit, Study Finds

Group of people holding smartphones in a circle with dark screens displayedA nationwide study of school cellphone restrictions found that locking away students’ phones dramatically reduces their use during the school day but produces little improvement in academic achievement, attendance, or classroom attention.

The findings, published in a working paper by the National Bureau of Economic Research (NBER), complicate the argument that removing phones from classrooms will automatically improve student performance and well-being.

The study, The Effects of School Phone Bans: National Evidence from Lockable Pouches, examined schools using Yondr pouches, which allow students to retain their phones while preventing access to them during the school day.

Researchers from Stanford University, Duke University, the University of Pennsylvania, and the University of Michigan analyzed standardized test scores, attendance records, disciplinary data, cellphone location information, and student surveys. Their research also incorporated a national survey that collected nearly 108,000 responses from educators across all 50 states.

The results suggest that the restrictions accomplish their immediate purpose: keeping students off their phones.

Teachers at schools adopting Yondr reported that the share of students using phones during class for personal reasons fell from 61% to 13%. Teacher satisfaction with school cellphone policies increased from approximately 26% to 75%.

Cellphone location data also showed substantial declines in device activity on school campuses, reaching roughly 30% by the third year after implementation.

Those changes, though, did not translate into broad academic gains.

Researchers found that average standardized test score improvements were essentially zero during the first three years following adoption. High schools experienced modest improvements, particularly in mathematics, where achievement increased by approximately 0.9 percentile points. Middle schools, meanwhile, experienced small declines in academic performance.

Attendance rates and chronic absenteeism showed virtually no measurable improvement.

The study also identified potential short-term consequences for student behavior and emotional well-being.

Disciplinary incidents increased during the first year of implementation, corresponding to an estimated 15% rise in suspension rates. Those effects diminished in subsequent years.

Researchers also found suggestive evidence that students' subjective well-being initially declined after the restrictions took effect before recovering and becoming positive two years later.

The researchers cautioned that the well-being findings were less conclusive because of limitations in the available survey data.

Despite expectations that restricting cellphone access would improve classroom engagement and reduce online harassment, the study found no clear evidence of improvements in students' self-reported attention or perceptions of online bullying.

The findings arrive as cellphone restrictions become increasingly common in American schools. According to the researchers, roughly two-thirds of U.S. states had enacted legislation limiting student cellphone access by 2026, while nearly 5,000 schools had adopted lockable pouches.

The trusted source for all job seekers
We have an extensive variety of listings for both academic and non-academic positions at postsecondary institutions.
Read More
The trusted source for all job seekers