For nearly two decades, Dr. Susana M. Muñoz has attended the Association for the Study of Higher Education's annual conference, connecting with colleagues and exploring research that challenges conventional thinking about colleges and universities.
But one moment at this year's gathering in San Juan, Puerto Rico, left the Colorado State University professor contemplating an uncomfortable reality about representation within the academic community.
During the presidential address, Dr. Muñoz said Dr. Robin Zape-tah-hol-ah Starr Minthorn, the first Indigenous person to lead the association, invited Indigenous scholars attending the conference to join her onstage.
The moment was meaningful, Dr. Muñoz said, but the relatively small number of scholars who assembled also underscored how much work remains to diversify the field.
"It gave me pause because if she could fit all of them on the stage with her, we're not doing a good job," said Dr. Muñoz, a professor in Colorado State University's higher education leadership program and associate director of its School of Education.
The moment captured a central theme of the association's 51st annual conference, held Nov. 3-6 at the Puerto Rico Convention Center. Under the banner "Land, Memory, and Power: Collective Movements to Revolutionize Higher Education," scholars examined the historical forces shaping colleges and universities, the communities they serve, and the voices that have traditionally been excluded from academic knowledge production.
The conference's program featured more than 200 research and scholarly sessions, 11 presidential sessions, keynote presentations, professional development opportunities, and networking events.
The conference also included a virtual day Oct. 22, extending participation beyond those who traveled to Puerto Rico.
For Dr. Minthorn, a professor and department chair of educational leadership and policy studies at the University of Oklahoma, the gathering represented an opportunity to challenge longstanding assumptions about whose experiences and knowledge matter in higher education.
In her February invitation to conference participants, Dr. Minthorn encouraged potential attendees to examine the relationship between academic institutions, colonial histories, and the communities connected to them.
"We arrive not as tourists, but as guests and allies, committed to uplifting silenced voices and honoring the communities to which our universities are tethered," she wrote.
That message carried particular significance in Puerto Rico, where questions of colonialism, cultural identity, and self-determination remain deeply connected to the island's history and present circumstances.
Conference organizers acknowledged San Juan as part of Borikén, the ancestral homeland of the Taíno people, and emphasized the contributions of Indigenous communities and the descendants of enslaved Africans to the island's culture and history.
The gathering marked ASHE's second conference in Puerto Rico in five years. Organizers encouraged attendees to build upon relationships established during the association's 2021 meeting rather than approach the island simply as a conference destination.
The program reflected those priorities through research addressing racial equity, educational access, institutional responsibility, and the experiences of historically marginalized populations.
Among the scheduled discussions was a presidential session examining how minority-serving institutions might respond to the retreat from diversity, equity, and inclusion initiatives. Other presentations addressed student persistence, educational pathways, and the policies shaping institutional opportunities.
For Muñoz, the opportunity to engage with innovative scholarship remains one of the gathering's greatest strengths.
She described the experience as a chance to be in community with scholars whose work pushes her to reconsider familiar ideas.
But Dr. Minthorn's presidential address stood apart from previous conferences, she said, particularly in its emphasis on making Indigenous scholars visible and challenging traditional approaches to producing academic knowledge.
The decision to bring those scholars onstage was both an acknowledgment of their contributions and a reminder of their limited representation in the profession.
The experience raised broader questions about how higher education institutions recruit, support, and elevate Indigenous researchers, as well as whose perspectives shape the scholarship that influences institutional policies and practices.
For other participants, the conference reinforced the importance of professional relationships and intellectual collaboration at a time when higher education faces significant political and institutional pressures.
Dr. Chinasa Elue, a professor of educational leadership and higher education at Kennesaw State University in Georgia who attended and presented research at the gathering, described the experience enthusiastically in an Instagram post. She expressed particular appreciation for presenting research alongside colleagues and learning from other scholars working across the field.
"One of my favorite things about the Association for the Study of Higher Education (ASHE) is being reminded of the power of community, collaboration, and scholarship to challenge our thinking and move higher education forward," Dr. Elue wrote.
Her reflections underscored another dimension of the annual gathering: the professional networks that sustain academic research and provide opportunities for scholars at different career stages to share ideas, receive feedback, and establish collaborations.
Those connections also offer opportunities to translate research into discussions about institutional practices, student experiences, and public policy.
The conference's emphasis on community and collective responsibility extended beyond the formal research presentations, challenging participants to consider how their work might contribute to institutional change.
For Dr. Muñoz, the image of Indigenous scholars gathered onstage offered a particularly enduring reminder of that responsibility.
Their visibility was important, she suggested, but the moment also made clear the need for higher education to create more opportunities for Indigenous scholars to contribute to the research and conversations shaping the field.














