Welcome to The EDU Ledger.com! We’ve moved from Diverse.
Welcome to The EDU Ledger! We’ve moved from Diverse: Issues In Higher Education.

Create a free The EDU Ledger account to continue reading

Supreme Court Lets California's Implicit Bias Training Requirement Stand

Stethoscope resting on medical documents with healthcare professional in backgroundThe U.S. Supreme Court has allowed a California requirement that physicians receive education on implicit bias to remain in place, declining on Monday to hear a challenge from a doctor who argued that the mandate violated her First Amendment rights.

The court declining to review Khatibi v. Yip leaves in place a lower court ruling that upheld the state's authority to require implicit bias instruction in continuing medical education courses, according to the Supreme Court's order and reporting by SCOTUSblog. Three justices indicated they would have heard the case.

California's law, which took effect in January 2022, requires continuing medical education courses for physicians and surgeons to incorporate instruction on implicit bias. The term refers to unconscious attitudes or stereotypes that can influence decisions, including how medical professionals diagnose and treat patients.

Under California Business and Professions Code Section 2190.1, courses must include examples of how implicit bias can contribute to disparities in health outcomes or strategies for addressing unintended biases in medical decision-making.

Dr. Azadeh Khatibi, a California ophthalmologist who develops and teaches continuing medical education courses, challenged the requirement alongside Do No Harm, an advocacy organization opposed to certain diversity and equity initiatives in medicine.

Khatibi argued that forcing private instructors to incorporate implicit bias instruction into courses violates their First Amendment rights. According to the Pacific Legal Foundation, which represented the challengers, Khatibi maintained that the requirement takes time away from clinical subjects, including retinal tumors and glaucoma, that she considers more relevant to her teaching.

The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit rejected the challenge, finding that California's extensive regulation of medical licensing and continuing education meant the required instruction constituted government speech rather than private expression protected from government interference. The court's reasoning was outlined in Justice Clarence Thomas' dissent and a Pacific Legal Foundation analysis of the case.

Thomas, joined by Justice Samuel Alito, dissented from the Supreme Court's decision not to hear the case. Justice Neil Gorsuch also indicated that he would have granted review, leaving the challengers one vote short of the four needed for the court to hear the case.

"A State cannot regulate its way out of First Amendment scrutiny," Thomas wrote, arguing that the lower court's reasoning could allow governments to exercise broad control over private educational instruction.

In a statement following the decision, the Pacific Legal Foundation expressed disappointment but pointed to the three justices' willingness to hear the case as encouragement for future legal challenges.

Although the Supreme Court's decision leaves California's requirement in place, it does not resolve the broader constitutional question of how much authority states have to dictate the content of continuing education courses.

The dispute could have implications beyond medicine, including for other licensed professions, such as law, in which states require continuing education as a condition of maintaining professional credentials. Thomas raised that possibility in his dissent, questioning whether the Ninth Circuit's reasoning could allow states to dictate what private instructors teach in other professional settings.

The trusted source for all job seekers
We have an extensive variety of listings for both academic and non-academic positions at postsecondary institutions.
Read More
The trusted source for all job seekers